A MIDSUMMER NIGHTMARE!
Keats House
★★★★
“a richly atmospheric experience that is at times unsettling, at times hilarious, and always captivating”
A Midsummer Nightmare!, presented by Midnight Circle Productions and helmed by visionary director Cecilie Fray, is a bold, genre-defying reimagining of Shakespeare’s classic. Produced by the Broadway World award-winning company, this hauntingly beautiful adaptation captures both the chaos and charm of the original while plunging it into darker, more dreamlike depths.
From the moment the audience enters the performance space, it’s clear this is not traditional theatre. Each venue on the company’s tour is transformed into an enchanted garden, drawing you into an immersive, almost interactive environment. With flickering lanterns, creeping fog, and a soft midsummer breeze, the setting evokes something between a dream and a gothic fairytale. If you look closely enough, or maybe just believe hard enough, you might catch a fairy slipping between the trees.
The production leans heavily into the surreal and eerie qualities of the play, amplifying the sense of mischief, confusion, and illusion that has always been at its heart. This isn’t just a “Midsummer Night’s Dream” with a twist, it’s a full-on nightmare, but one that retains the warmth and wit of Shakespeare’s writing. The result is a richly atmospheric experience that is at times unsettling, at times hilarious, and always captivating.
One of the most impressive elements of the production is the cast’s dual role as both performers and musicians. Every actor on stage contributes not just to the storytelling but also to the show’s live soundscape, through haunting harmonies, folk-inspired instrumentation, and ambient vocalizations. This creates a constantly shifting sonic world that mirrors the instability of the enchanted forest and the characters’ emotional turmoil.
Standout performances abound. Nadia Lamin brings a touching vulnerability and fierce comic energy to Helena, whose desperate love for Demetrius, played with arrogance and occasional softness by Charlie Macrae-Tod, anchors some of the play’s most painfully funny scenes. Their chemistry adds fresh depth to one of the play’s most turbulent love stories.
Sam Bird is a magnetic presence as Puck, or Robin Goodfellow, the mischievous fairy who gleefully causes much of the chaos. His physicality, timing, and voice work bring an unpredictable edge to the role, while Chloe Orrock’s regal and brooding Oberon offers a powerful counterbalance. The decision to gender-swap the fairy king adds further intrigue to their dynamic.
Meanwhile, Titania, portrayed by Kennedy Jopson, exudes grace and quiet power, while her scenes with Bottom, played by Jed McLoughlin, are some of the show’s most bizarre and oddly tender moments. Their vocal performances in particular, lyrical, eerie, and emotionally charged, elevate the production’s dreamlike tone.
Costume and set design deserve special mention. Cloaked in earth tones, shadowy veils, and delicate lights, the aesthetic of the production embraces both decay and beauty. The forest feels alive, filled with secrets and whispers, while the actors’ costumes suggest they’ve wandered out of a folk horror film. The visuals, heighten the sense that this is a space out of time, where love, identity, and reality blur.
Despite its dark tone, the production doesn’t lose the play’s original humor. In fact, the comedic moments shine more brightly against the gothic backdrop, and the clever use of physical comedy and timing ensures the audience is constantly engaged, sometimes laughing, sometimes holding their breath.
If there’s one critique, it’s that the immersive elements might not work equally well in all venues, depending on the audience’s proximity to the action. However, this feels like a small price to pay for such an ambitious and original reimagining of a well-known classic.
In the end, A Midsummer Nightmare! is exactly what its title promises, a dream turned on its head. This production does not aim to comfort; it aims to enchant, unsettle, and surprise. With its stunning performances, innovative staging, and gothic flair, it invites us to rediscover Shakespeare not as a museum piece, but as a living, breathing spell of theatre.
A MIDSUMMER NIGHTMARE!
Keats House then UK Tour continues
Reviewed on 13th June 2025
by Beatrice Morandi
Photography by Roj Whitelock
Previously reviewed by Beatrice:
INSIDE GIOVANNI’S ROOM | ★★★★★ | SADLER’S WELLS EAST | June 2025
MACBETH | ★★★★ | BREAD & ROSES THEATRE | May 2025
JORDAN GRAY: IS THAT A C*CK IN YOUR POCKET, OR ARE YOU JUST HERE TO KILL ME? | ★★★★★ | SOHO THEATRE | May 2025
FAYGELE | ★★★★★ | MARYLEBONE THEATRE | May 2025
ROMEO AND JULIET | ★★★★★ | HACKNEY EMPIRE | April 2025
THE GUEST | ★★★★★ | OMNIBUS THEATRE | April 2025
