Tag Archives: thespyinthestalls

THE GAMBLER

★★★★

Coronet Theatre

THE GAMBLER

Coronet Theatre

★★★★

“a vital and dramatic production that draws us out of our comfort zone”

Fyodor Dostoevsky wrote his short novel, ‘The Gambler’, under pressure to repay gambling debts. Originally set in a hotel and casino in an unnamed German city, the themes inevitably reflect his own life and his own addiction to roulette. He even bet the publishing rights of all his past and future works, wagering that he would complete the novel within thirty days. He did manage to finish the book in time, but the success of this particular gamble shouldn’t detract from his powerfully cautionary tale.

Criticised for being rushed out and for not being as polished as his major works, it was also lauded for its honest description of addiction, focusing on repetition and loops of behaviour. This is the core that the Kyoto based company, Chiten Theatre, have grasped on for their unique and intensely stylised interpretation of the story. To reap the full benefit of this production, there are two bits of homework to do: become familiar with the synopsis and brush up a little on Japanese culture and its social fabric. The former is easy – it’s a short novel but failing that there are plenty of summaries on the internet. What is more difficult, however, is understanding and adopting the mindset of the creators of this piece of theatre. But once achieved, one’s enjoyment of the show intensifies immeasurably.

All things aside, director Motoi Miura’s staging is visually stunning. Itaru Sugiyama’s set is a roulette wheel that revolves while the ensemble cast are grouped around a table at its centre. As it turns, they break away, moving with choreographed precision. Sometimes it is beautifully fluid, sometimes bizarrely jagged. The entire show is underscored by the pulsing sounds of experimental rock trio, ‘kukangendai’. It appears fragmented and chaotic, yet we sense that there is some sort of purpose. The actors seldom speak to each other, instead addressing the audience. In Japanese, the surtitles are like soundbites. Some are more poignant than others, but all are quite pertinent. Translated by Ikuo Kameyama, we are given a sense of the story, and I guess it is up to our emotions to fill in the rest.

The main problem is that there is a lot of sensory overload. Repetition is key – but it has been taken to its extreme. The delivery is a high decibel monotone and the constant banging of the table to punctuate the lines eventually grates. We do see the various personalities, however. Takahide Akimoto stands out as the central figure, Alexei, consumed by his gambling and also consumed by the opposing feelings of anger and resignation his addiction triggers. Midori Aioi is charismatic as love interest Polina, displaying a cool detachment towards Alexei. Satoko Abe as ‘Grandmother’ – the wealthy, elderly aunt who loses her fortune – injects some much-needed humour into the piece, displaying some remarkable physical agility. Each of the cast has an individuality but more often than not we only see the ensemble working as one machine. Whilst this isn’t a fault, it does distance us from any real emotional involvement.

The structure is perfect, though, for the simple plot. Basically, the eponymous gambler – Alexei – bets, wins, loses, promises to stop, then returns to the roulette table. The show fixes (fixates even) on this loop and we feel trapped within it. It is slightly disturbing and uncomfortable, a little too long, but ultimately powerful. Like the subject matter, the play itself lures us in then ensnares us. We breathe a sigh of relief when it is over but some part of us feels the temptation to give it another go. In that way it is extremely clever. It is a niche experience and will probably suffer from its narrow appeal, yet it is a vital and dramatic production that draws us out of our comfort zone. It might not be to everyone’s taste but it’s definitely worth taking a bet on.



THE GAMBLER

Coronet Theatre

Reviewed on 5th February 2026

by Jonathan Evans

Photography by Shotaro Ichihashi


 

 

 

 

THE GAMBLER

THE GAMBLER

THE GAMBLER

DEBATE: BALDWIN VS BUCKLEY

★★★★

Wilton’s Music Hall

DEBATE: BALDWIN VS BUCKLEY

Wilton’s Music Hall

★★★★

“a vital reminder that dangerous ideas often come speaking eloquently and dressed in a nice suit”

In 1965, two prominent American intellectuals, acclaimed Black author James Baldwin and white conservative commentator William F. Buckley Jr. met at Cambridge University to debate the motion ‘The American dream is at the expense of the American negro’ before a crowd of students, who would vote for a winner. The debate was broadcast on television and has become a reference point for the arguments of the Civil Rights movement. Now, the American Vicarious company brings this debate to the London stage, adapted and directed by Christopher McElroen with production director Erica Laird.

I don’t intend to relitigate the outcome of the debate, won as convincingly by Baldwin here as it was in 1965 (by a landslide in the room of 544 votes to 164, and equally emphatically in public opinion), but as a piece of theatre it remains compelling. The simple staging of four chairs, mimicking the stage of the Cambridge Union where the debate was held, focuses attention on the participants and their words. This staging is complemented by video from the television broadcast projected onto the rear wall of the stage, in which a presenter introduces the debate, and the chair introduces speakers, first Cambridge students David Heycock and Jeremy Burford and then Baldwin and Buckley. The students and Buckley wear black tie and Baldwin a suit.

Arnell Powell is excellent as Baldwin. He channels the, often barely contained, anger of the writer at the injustices of America, commanding the stage when delivering his speech. He masterfully conveys Baldwin’s nuanced and powerful arguments on systemic racism, the reality of the American dream and the crushing dehumanisation of both Black and white communities enacted by racism. Seated when other speakers have the floor, he subtly and amusingly, reacts facially to the speeches of the other parties, and pointedly refuses to rise to the deliberate provocations of Buckley.

For his part, Eric T. Miller brilliantly embodies the smarmy southern-gentleman charm used by Buckley to put an acceptable face on unacceptable ideas. This approach may not be as successful in 2026 as in 1965, at least in this room, as many of his arguments elicited contemptuous snorts from the audience, which Miller dealt with excellently, engaging with the audience members and rebutting them without breaking character. His grandstanding and more confrontational approach stands in contrast to Baldwin’s.

The opening debate between two Cambridge undergraduates sets the stage, with Christopher Wareham as David Heycock supporting Baldwin’s position, and Tom Kiteley as Jeremy Burford, with Buckley. Both are strong, evidencing the swagger of self-confident (and perhaps self-important) students, Kiteley is especially impressive as the intellectually slippery Burford arguing almost at cross purposes to the motion, and avoiding the more moral arguments put forward strongly by Wareham. All four performances are exemplary, and the format of the piece affords each cast member the opportunity to shine.

Debate is a timely intervention in contemporary political discourse. Despite the setting giving an appearance of ‘doing politics the right way’, Buckley’s duplicitous and destabilising rhetorical tactics undermine debate, and their influence is evident in far-right commentators today. He deploys obviously cherry-picked statistics to support his point, which are neither strictly relevant nor easy to refute, as well as presenting fringe cases as an argument against systemic issues. He also shifts the goalposts of the debate, largely avoiding the motion and arguing that Baldwin wants to destroy Western civilisation. When pressed on this, he quotes from Baldwin: ‘the only thing that white people have that black people need… is power’, laying bare the white supremacy at the foundation of his understanding of Western civilisation.

Again, the outcome of the debate itself has been long decided on the strength of Baldwin’s position, but this new re-enactment is a vital reminder that dangerous ideas often come speaking eloquently and dressed in a nice suit.



DEBATE: BALDWIN VS BUCKLEY

Wilton’s Music Hall

Reviewed on 4th February 2026

by Rob Tomlinson

Photography by the American Vicarious


 

 

 

 

DEBATE

DEBATE

DEBATE