Tag Archives: Amy Punter

NERO

★★★

Southwark Playhouse Elephant

NERO

Southwark Playhouse Elephant

★★★

“As messy as life itself, and like life itself, ‘Nero’ is to be celebrated.”

If Shakespeare had tackled the subject of the first century Roman Emperor Nero, it would have probably fallen into the category of one of his ‘problem plays’. Steven Sater and the late Duncan Sheik – the duo behind ‘Spring Awakening’ – are suffering the same fate with their musical “Nero” that resists any tidy classification. Nearly twenty-three years in the making, it is still unsure whether its genre is comedy, tragedy or history. Hedging its bets, it has decided to encompass all three. But rather than blending its lighter comic elements with the darker unsettling subject matter into a cohesive whole, it segregates them; ploughing much of the humour into the first act while saving the psychological drama for after the interval. We come away unsure whether Nero was a damaged, camp Mother’s Boy, a victim of circumstance or just a plain psychopath. But the real tragedy is that we don’t really care.

Coming with an armoury of trigger warnings, it doesn’t shy away from the morally ambiguous themes. The aesthetics are those of a Greek tragedy. Nero himself was a frustrated artist – a wannabe celebrity who wanted to tread the boards rather than rule an empire. In this vein, director Lindsay Posner’s aim is to entertain rather than instruct. Andrew Barth Feldman presents Nero as an androgynous cabaret performer turned Glam Rock star, unbelievably self-centred while those around him fall. The body count is high before we even get started, and by the time we reach the finale we have lost count of the corpses. It is no spoiler to reveal that he gets his just desserts (this is Roman history after all). These are the more successful moments, ultimately quite stirring, as Nero is haunted and taunted by the ghosts of his victims and his actions. The finale is, indeed, explosive, although it takes an Emperor’s lifetime to get there.

The journey is well signposted, through the music but also through its expositional text. Frequent asides to the audience, and overblown oration tells us what is going on more than we are shown. Georgia Lowe’s set is nothing more than a red velvet backdrop which disappears at interval to reveal a mirrored back wall in which we see ourselves beyond the cast. Whether that is a clever metaphor remains unclear. Costume supervisor Maybelle Laye has transported RuPaul’s Drag Race back in time to a forum full of toga-clad officials, while Tony Gayle’s sound design is trying to recreate the amphitheatres; booming with too much echo at times. Much of the ensemble’s vocals are lost, but the lead players, when they break into song, cut through to reveal the fine vocal talents on display.

Sheik’s score is similarly eclectic, to say the least, from the Latin influenced Bossa Nova of ‘Quelle Surprise’ to the sultry, smoky blues of ‘The Bosom of the Moon’ (Rhianne-Louise McCaulsky in wonderful form as Nero’s ill-fated mistress Poppea). Nabi Brown, as the mute wife of Nero, frequently revisits her soulful ballad ‘The Winter Wind’ (which has as many pre-reprises as reprises). There is the bouncy ‘A Double Dip of Darkness’ (again reprised), and the gorgeous tango ‘Ghost in a Box’: musical but menacing and a number which brings James Cousins’ choreography to the fore. The undoubted highlight is ‘The Lover from Hell’, a duet between Andrew Barth Feldman and Sally Dexter who plays his mother Agrippina. This relationship is central to the story with Dexter’s performance a mix of Lady Macbeth and Oedipus’ mother.

The score may lay itself open to accusations of being a bit of a jumble, but it is the saving grace. Sater’s book is more disordered, although the performances lend it enough cohesion for us to forgive the lack of direction in the narrative. It is sometimes uncomfortable, sometimes ridiculous, yet underlying it is a pertinence that is serendipitous. We are witnessing the story of a self-indulgent and debauched tyrant – compulsive and corrupt, with no sense of right or wrong; who allegedly burned a city to pave the way for his ‘Golden House’. Motivated by cruelty rather than a sense of justice he made scapegoats of his dissenters, whilst swayed by flattery. He was eventually declared a public enemy. This was all two thousand years ago, but the description is all too modern. Is that enough to put this in the category of tragedy? “Nero”, as a musical, is still unsure. The comedy sits uneasily in the context. But ultimately, it is entertainment. As messy as life itself, and like life itself, “Nero” is to be celebrated (the show that is, not the man).


NERO

Southwark Playhouse Elephant

Reviewed on 6th November 2026

by Jonathan Evans

Photography by Manuel Harlen

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

NERO

NERO

NERO

NERO