Tag Archives: Ashley D Gayle

THE ANASTASIA FILE

★★★

UK Tour

THE ANASTASIA FILE

Theatre Royal Windsor

★★★

“solid and captivating”

Anna Anderson (born Franziska Schanzkowska in 1896) famously claimed to be the Grand Duchess Anastasia Nikolaevna – the youngest daughter of Nicholas II, the last Tsar of Russia. The fact that she was supposed to have been murdered, along with the rest of the whole family, by Bolshevik revolutionaries cast doubt on her claim, but she stood her ground until the end. It was only after her death that DNA evidence proved once and for all that there was no match, and none of the Tsar’s daughters survived the massacre. This is no spoiler; Royce Ryton’s 1978 play “The Anastasia File” was also written before this, and consequently the conclusion is left open.

The play begins in 1920, when a young woman is pulled from a canal following a failed attempt to take her own life. Deeply troubled and apparently suffering from memory loss, she is placed in an institution while doctors and the police try to establish who she is. Convincingly portrayed by Jenny Seagrove, the woman is initially fearful of any human communication or contact, but as she is slowly and carefully coaxed out of her trauma-induced silence, clues are uncovered that suggest she is much more than she appears to be. It is evident that she is highly educated, fluent in many languages, well connected and privileged. And she possesses much intimate knowledge of the Romanov family that an outsider wouldn’t have. The authorities take her seriously, as do certain relatives of the Tsar’s family; but opinions repeatedly change throughout the play. The audience follow these shifts like a crowd on the centre court at Wimbledon. Is her memory true, or is she just an extremely skilled imposter?

Crucial to Ryton’s interpretation of the saga is the fact that an awful lot of money is at stake. If Anastasia can prove who she really is, there is a huge gold deposit in England waiting for her, left there as an inheritance by the Tsar. Two alleged aunts who visit her in the sanitorium initially recognise her as the daughter, although on discovering this goldmine rapidly change their minds and throw her identity into doubt. Rosie Thomson plays both with a mix of gravity and humour, in addition multi-rolling as various nursemaids and ancillary staff. Ashley D. Gayle adopts many characters too, switching accents and personalities with confidence and panache. Simon Shepherd is the leading investigator, and Anastasia’s closest ally. The chemistry between Seagrove and Shepherd propels the narrative, but doesn’t always lift it into the air, while the mystery never truly grips in director Roy Marsden’s wordy and static staging. The second act picks up the pace as the two protagonists become more animated, but the increase in momentum leads to a slight glossing over of her later years.

The lack of theatricality is mirrored in the sparse set. There is minimal clutter, which does allow the narrative to take centre stage. The story is fascinating in itself, but the performers seem to be relying on this intrinsic interest, rather than using the collective talent on stage to draw us in. It is a demanding play that requires close attention to the words, and we are told a lot and shown little. Shepherd captures well, however, the mix of loyalty and scepticism that his character commands, while Seagrove seizes on moments of aching vulnerability that lie beneath a veneer of arrogance and stubbornness.

We are left to make up our own minds. Even if we know the historical facts of the outcome, the show still manages to end on a question mark, which ultimately makes for an intriguing evening. We are given both sides of the story, with no verdict. After show conversations are divided but subdued; a fair reflection of the play itself that lacks tension in an otherwise solid and captivating drama.

 



THE ANASTASIA FILE

Theatre Royal Windsor

Reviewed on 30th September 2026

by Jonathan Evans

Photography by Simon Vail

 

 

 

 

 

 

THE ANASTASIA FILE

THE ANASTASIA FILE

THE ANASTASIA FILE

DEATH OF ENGLAND: CLOSING TIME

★★★★

@SohoPlace

DEATH OF ENGLAND: CLOSING TIME at @SohoPlace

★★★★

“Duncan-Brewster and Doherty are simply thrilling to watch”

“Closing Time” is the third instalment of the “Death of England” trilogy of plays by Clint Dyer and Roy Williams. It has been a month since the first two – “Michael” and “Delroy”. During these first two monologues we were introduced to two off stage characters: Michael’s sister, Carly; and Delroy’s mother, Denise. We feel we know them both already such was the dynamic story telling of the actors. The anticipation is high as we wait to meet them in the flesh. We are not disappointed. From the moment Denise (Sharon Duncan-Brewster) and Carly (Erin Doherty) explode onto the stage we know we are in for another high-octane, scatter-gun ninety minutes of thought-provoking drama.

This time, though, it moves a little too fast. We are given no room to breathe as the two monologues compete and merge, overlap and clash, like a frantic tarantella dance; both women looking to purge the poisons that seem to have inflicted themselves and those around them. They spit and they rant, never knowing whether to attack or embrace. They attract and repel each other in equal measure, but therein lies our reservations. We, too, are unsure how far to be drawn in. Although there is no fourth wall there is an invisible barrier that keeps us at arm’s length this time. Perhaps there is just too much ranting (the monarchy, racism, colonialism, cancel culture, white privilege) or the delivery is just simply too fast, but we are less moved by the end than we were by their predecessors.

Duncan-Brewster’s Denise is simply captivating, however, as the accomplished yet frustrated chef. On her way to her dream, she has been running a food business in the East End. But it is closing down – or rather being closed down. Helping her pack up is her ‘daughter-in-sin’, Carly. Doherty gives a fierce, fire-cracker performance, her character sweeping the stage like a tornado. There is no eye of the storm, and Carly has no eye on the consequences of her actions. Her rebellious energy is intricately misplaced, epitomised in a drunken outburst (hilarious, yet ideologically as unsound as you can get) that is captured on camera and sent viral. Our cancel culture is brutally examined as these ill-chosen words lead to the collapse of Denise’s business. The causes and effects are brilliantly and dramatically evoked as the two actors swing between blame, forgiveness, defiance and pleading.

Still present is Benjamin Grant’s and Pete Malkin’s powerful and atmospheric sound design with its orchestral stabs, muted underscoring and thrilling realism; complemented by Jackie Shemesh’s lighting with its staccato shifts in perfect rhythm to the dialogue. The leitmotifs are all there, but the familiarity now lends an air of predictability. Similarly, we also start to feel that the characters’ views belong more to the writers; an impression that was absent in the first two monologues. Yet, despite a creeping impartiality in the text, we ultimately feel the magnetism of, and empathise with, these two broken personalities who show us that reconciliation is never completely out of reach. Duncan-Brewster and Doherty are simply thrilling to watch.

A month ago, I wrote that plays like “Death of England” are what keep English theatre well and truly alive – beating in the heart of the West End like the vital organ it is. By the time we reach “Closing Time” the sentiment still holds true, if a little wavering by now. But any signs of arrhythmia are swiftly curtailed by the outstanding performances.

 


DEATH OF ENGLAND: CLOSING TIME at @SohoPlace

Reviewed on 28th August 2024

by Jonathan Evans

Photography by Helen Murray

 

 

 

 

 

 

Previously reviewed at this venue:

DEATH OF ENGLAND: DELROY | ★★★★★ | July 2024
DEATH OF ENGLAND: MICHAEL | ★★★★★ | July 2024
THE LITTLE BIG THINGS | ★★★★ | September 2023
BROKEBACK MOUNTAIN | ★★★★★ | May 2023

DEATH OF ENGLAND: CLOSING TIME

DEATH OF ENGLAND: CLOSING TIME

Click here to see our Recommended Shows page