JEEZUS!
Underbelly Boulevard
★★★½
“irreverent, inventive, and occasionally chaotic”
Born in late-80s Lima to a mother who calls him her “miracle baby,” Jesús grows up in the shadow of both the church and his homophobic father’s military career. As he prepares for his first holy communion, Jesús finds himself navigating life and faith. For while the church hails him as a model altar boy, he is experiencing revelations of his own — namely, a growing attraction to none other than Jesus Christ himself, whose long hair and big feet leave the boy questioning everything he knows about where worship begins and desire ends.
It’s a setup ripe for melodrama, but Alpaqa Theatre Collective’s Jeezus! opens at Soho’s Underbelly Boulevard with a wink rather than a sermon. As Jesús (played throughout by Sergio Antonio Maggiolo) struts onto the stage, adorned in bright white and purple ecclesiastical garments (Carolina Rieckhof) alongside Guido Garcia Lueches (who multi-roles throughout), their innuendo-laden script quickly sets up a bawdy, irreverent look at faith and queer love.
The production makes inventive use of its small space. A screen at the back of the stage projects chapter-like titles that borrow from ecclesiastical events and Bible passages, guiding the audience through Jesús’ journey and occasionally pairing with playful lighting cues that draw out some of the show’s recurring motifs. There’s even a full AV sequence that leans into a deliberate “so-bad-it’s-good” aesthetic — a choice that fits perfectly with the show’s irreverent humour and self-awareness.
Laura Killen’s direction keeps the energy high and the tone well judged, ensuring the chaos always feels intentional rather than uncontrolled. At times, her touch even elevates the script with knowing nods — there’s a particularly great scene in which the pair subtly re-enact famous Mary and Jesus imagery while talking. The only criticism is that some of the staging sits too low on the floor, meaning those beyond the third row miss out on parts of the action.
Special mention must be given to both actors, who deliver excellent performances throughout. Antonio Maggiolo is superb as the beating heart of the show, with strong physical comedy, while Garcia Lueches’ multi-role performance shows incredible comic timing and range, providing something new and fresh to play off in every scene. From perverted priests to a scene where he bounces effortlessly between Jesús’ mother and father — sometimes mid-sentence — and even the son of God himself, there’s no role he doesn’t take on with aplomb.
The music flits between a range of genres — from acoustic ballads to energetic pop — and at one point even features a revised rendition of Carmina Burana: O Fortuna that will have you chuckling (a sentence I never thought I’d write). Both the music and vocals do their job with conviction and sincerity, even if this isn’t the sort of score that’ll stick in your head on the journey home. The dance choreography (Vivian Gabel), though inherently basic, carries an earnest energy that feels true to the production’s scrappy, heartfelt tone. This isn’t a West End-scale musical, nor does it try to be; instead, Jeezus! succeeds as a piece that’s genuinely greater than the sum of its parts.
And despite the shock value and bawdy entertainment (I imagine devout Catholics will find it a harder watch than this lapsed one), there’s a tenderness underpinning the entire piece. At its heart, the show is less concerned with provocation and more interested in reconciling queer identity with faith — in exploring how devotion and desire can coexist. That emotional thread keeps the show grounded, even when the humour teeters toward excess (there’s one moment, in particular, where it feels the dick jokes might tip the show over the edge, though thankfully it never does).
As with many Fringe productions, you’re often left in one of two camps: grateful it was only an hour, or wishing it had the space to breathe; this firmly falls into the latter. Its pace is brisk — enjoyable, yes — but at times it skims across the surface of ideas that deserve a deeper dive. It leaves you wondering how much more potent it could be with just twenty extra minutes to let those emotional beats land and explore characters in greater depth.
Still, that brevity doesn’t dampen its charm. At its best, Jeezus! feels like a two-man fusion of recent West End successes — Operation Mincemeat and The Book of Mormon — part camp parody, part heartfelt confession. It’s irreverent, inventive, and occasionally chaotic, but behind its blasphemous grin beats a very sincere heart.
JEEZUS!
Underbelly Boulevard
Reviewed on 16th October 2025
by Daniel Outis
Photography by Charlie Flint
