Tag Archives: Alejandro Martín Aparicio

 The Problem With Fletcher Mott

Drayton Arms

The Problem With Fletcher Mott

The Problem With Fletcher Mott

Drayton Arms Theatre

Reviewed – 17th February 2019



“in the main, the energy and talent of the performers was this show’s other great strength”


The Problem with Fletcher Mott began its life at Goldsmiths College, and premiered last year at the Tristan Bates. It is being presented over two nights at The Drayton Arms as a work in progress, to garner audience feedback; this review is written with that in mind.

The musical is the brain child of Jack Miles – writer of the book, music and lyrics – who also plays a mean guitar in the wonderfully tight three man band. Music is clearly the driver here, and is, most emphatically, the strongest weapon in Mr. Miles’ armoury; there are some terrific songs in this piece. He is at his best as a composer in the high-energy numbers such as The Concept and The Power of the Pen, and he clearly relishes fast and furious W.S.Gilbert-like lyrical frenzy – present throughout, but particularly in evidence in The Headache, a herculean feat of articulation, splendidly sung by Lucy Ogilvie as Angela. The slower numbers are less successful, and the show really loses energy in the second half. The final three songs are pretty lacklustre and it seems a great shame to finish with The Apology, which is the weakest number of all.

The book is, unfortunately, a far cry from the standard of the music, both in terms of the plot itself, and the spoken interludes. The main character, the hapless Fletcher Mott, is not sufficiently interesting for the audience to be fully invested in; nor are the stakes of his situation sufficiently high. He is a non-descript writer, who fails to write a play; ultimately, what does it matter? The show’s padding consists mostly of incredibly broad comedy, which comes across as strangely dated in such a contemporary piece. Being asked to laugh at ‘yobbos’ in baseball caps talking like middle class academics seemed almost offensively retro, as did the tourists sketch. It all seemed faintly juvenile, as did the badly written swearing. Lines like ‘You’ve got a shitload of shit writing to shit’ brought the professionalism of the enterprise right down, and suddenly the cast seemed like a bunch of silly teenagers out to shock. It jarred every time, as, in the main, the energy and talent of the performers was this show’s other great strength.

Although the character of Fletcher’s inner critic was never entirely convincing, Rose Dickson sang with strength, sass and clarity throughout, and Hugh Train’s wonderfully energetic performance as Dan was a treat, culminating in his fabulous rendition of The Writer’s Mind in the second half. The ensemble singing was always on point, and all the performers fully committed to the work, which drove the show forward even in its duller or more ridiculous moments.

The Problem with Fletcher Mott feels like a talented musical theatre composer flexing his muscles. We will definitely be hearing more from Jack Miles, but Fletcher feels like a stepping stone. It might be an idea to collaborate on the writing too; to release a bit of creative control, allow another voice in, and see where that takes him. Watch this space.


Reviewed by Rebecca Crankshaw

Photography by Rosalind Steven


The Problem With Fletcher Mott

Drayton Arms Theatre


Previously reviewed at this venue:
Are There Female Gorillas? | ★★★★ | April 2018
The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee | ★★★★ | May 2018
No Leaves on my Precious Self | ★★ | July 2018
The Beautiful Game | ★★★ | August 2018
Baby | ★★ | October 2018
Jake | ★★★ | October 2018
Love, Genius and a Walk | | October 2018
Boujie | ★★★½ | November 2018
Out of Step | ★★ | January 2019


Click here to see more of our latest reviews on thespyinthestalls.com


The Problem With Fletcher Mott – 4 Stars


The Problem With Fletcher Mott

Tristan Bates Theatre

Reviewed – 15th September 2018


funny and genuine and well meaning


The Problem With Fletcher Mott could have chosen to be a heavy, hard to digest piece of theatre. Dissecting the role that personal and professional anxiety play in creative processes could easily be an immense task that leaves its audience drained and unmotivated. On the other hand, this piece of theatre, put together confidently by students from Goldsmith’s University, held a strong sense that this specific brand of anxiety is only as powerful as we allow it to be – and, what’s more, that perhaps it’s necessary in small doses for any kind of creativity to take place.

There were certain elements of the structure that were perhaps a little outdated: presenting anxiety in a physical form does feel a bit like an easy fix to the enormous problem of how to represent mental health issues on stage. However, I would definitely prefer to focus on what this piece is saying rather than how it says it. Amid a comedically mountainous heap of problems: The dream girl stolen swept off her feet by a more successful, more popular upstairs neighbour, the looming deadlines for new work and the ever present ghost of a past successful play that came and went six years ago, there’s a very emotionally well tuned message. That said, it never becomes preachy.

The protagonist is far from always right, and neither is anyone else. Instead, the entire cohort of characters just spent an hour and a bit being horrified by the extent to which everyone around them could be wrong, and personally I think that worked better.

All in all, The Problem With Fletcher Mott was just funny and genuine and well meaning, and really that’s all it needs to be.


Reviewed by Grace Patrick


The Problem With Fletcher Mott

Tristan Bates Theatre as past of Mélange: The New Musical Theatre Festival



Click here to see more of our latest reviews on thespyinthestalls.com